Open: Thu 5:30 PM - 7:00 PM
$399,900
Active
3
Beds
3
Baths
1760
Sqft
0.33
Acres
1111 Brick Landing Pl, Webster, NY 14580
MLS#: R1691763
Penfield vs Webster NY: Housing, Taxes, Schools, Commute & Lifestyle Compared
A side-by-side comparison of two of Monroe County's most popular east-side suburbs — covering housing, taxes, schools, commute, and what buyers actually notice first.
Originally published July 7, 2026
Penfield and Webster come up together in almost every conversation I have with buyers looking at Monroe County's east side. Both towns border Irondequoit Bay, both feed into strong public school systems, and both offer a wider mix of housing than the village-centered suburbs closer to Pittsford or Fairport. But the two towns are not interchangeable, and buyers who spend real time in each community usually come away with a clear preference.
Penfield is the larger, more land-spread suburb, built around town parks, golf clubs, and a handful of historic hamlets rather than one central downtown. Webster pairs a walkable Village core with direct Lake Ontario frontage and one of the region's largest single employers on its own soil. Both carry a real tax premium versus the national average, and both feed top-tier school districts — but the details of housing stock, tax rate, commute, and daily lifestyle diverge in ways that matter once you start touring homes.
This guide breaks down what actually matters when you're choosing between these two communities — housing inventory and price points, property tax math, school districts, commute patterns, and the lifestyle differences buyers often only discover once they've lived in the area a while.
Quick Reference — Penfield vs Webster at a Glance
| Category | Penfield NY | Webster NY |
| County | Monroe County | Monroe County |
| Location | East of Rochester, along Irondequoit Bay | North of Penfield, on Lake Ontario & the Bay |
| School District | Penfield Central (6 schools, K–12) | Webster Central (2 high schools, 11 schools total) |
| Recent Median Home Price | ~$325,000–$375,000 (12-mo. median ~$368K) | Wide spread — high-$200,000s to ~$400,000+ |
| Median Effective Property Tax Rate | ~2.65% of assessed value | ~2.36% of assessed value |
| Commute to Downtown Rochester | ~20–25 min via I-590 | ~15–25 min via Route 104 |
| Character | Spread across historic hamlets; parks & golf clubs | Walkable Village core + Lake Ontario shoreline |
| Signature Employer / Anchor | Retail corridor along Routes 441 & 250 | Xerox's ~1,000-acre campus |
| Signature Recreation | Harris Whalen Park, Thousand Acre Swamp, 2 golf clubs | Webster Park (550 acres, Lake Ontario), North Ponds Park |
Jump to a Section
| 🏘️ Community Overview 🏠 Housing & Home Prices 💰 Property Taxes 🏫 School Districts | 🌳 Lifestyle & Water Access 🚗 Commute & Convenience ✅ Who Tends to Choose Each ❓ Frequently Asked Questions |
🏘️ Community Overview: Two Different Layouts
Penfield and Webster share a border and a comparable reputation for schools and quality of life, but they're organized very differently on the ground. Understanding the underlying layout of each town goes a long way toward knowing which one will feel right before you've toured a single house.
Penfield: Hamlets, Parkland, and Established Neighborhoods
Penfield doesn't have a single downtown the way some Rochester suburbs do. Instead, its identity is spread across a handful of historic hamlets — the original Penfield hamlet near the Four Corners, Panorama, East Penfield, and the Whalen Park and Five Mile Line neighborhoods among them. The town's oldest commercial site, the historic Daisy Flour Mill, now houses Rising Storm Brewing Company at The Mill, one of the newer additions to a growing local dining scene. The housing stock ranges from mid-century ranches and colonials in established, tree-lined subdivisions to newer executive-style construction in developments like Highland Estates, where 2-plus-acre lots have been carved out of former farmland on the town's eastern edge.
Penfield's calling card is genuinely its parks and green space — more than ten town parks and preserves, including the Thousand Acre Swamp Preserve and the Four Mile Creek Trail, plus two private golf clubs. For a full neighborhood-by-neighborhood breakdown, the complete guide to living in Penfield goes deeper than this comparison can.
Webster: A Village Core Plus Lake Ontario Frontage
Webster sits just north of Penfield, wrapped by Lake Ontario on its north edge and Irondequoit Bay to the west, with Wayne County along its eastern border. Unlike Penfield, Webster includes both a Town and a separately incorporated Village — established in 1905 and still governing its own police, public works, and zoning — which gives it a genuine main-street core along Ridge Road in addition to its suburban subdivisions. Unincorporated hamlets, including West Webster and part of Union Hill, round out the rest of the town.
Webster's other defining feature is Xerox, which owns roughly 1,000 acres in town — one of the largest single landholdings by any company in the United States — giving the town an employment anchor that Penfield doesn't have. For the full picture, our complete guide to living in Webster covers the Village-versus-Town distinction and neighborhood specifics in more detail.
🏠 Housing & Home Prices: What Your Budget Gets You
The single biggest practical difference buyers notice is what their budget actually buys in each town. Penfield's pricing has settled into a fairly narrow, predictable band. Webster's pricing spreads much wider, because its inventory ranges from modest village and interior-subdivision homes all the way up to bay- and lakefront properties that carry a real premium.
Penfield Housing Market
Penfield's housing stock is dominated by mid-century ranches and colonials on established, mature-tree lots, along with 1980s–2000s subdivisions along Five Mile Line and Panorama and larger new-construction lots toward East Penfield. Recent sale data puts the town's 12-month median sale price right around $368,000, up roughly 5% year over year, though month-to-month figures bounce between the low-$300,000s and the high-$300,000s depending on the specific mix of homes that closed. Well-priced, move-in-ready homes in Penfield still sell quickly — commonly within a week to ten days — and new construction is limited mostly to infill developments like Highland Estates.
What $350,000–$375,000 Buys in Penfield
At this price point in Penfield, expect a well-maintained three-to-four bedroom ranch or colonial built between the 1970s and 1990s, on a 0.2–0.4 acre lot in an established subdivision near Five Mile Line, Panorama, or the Whalen Park neighborhood. Updated kitchens and baths show up more often at the top of this range; homes at this price generally move within one to two weeks in a normal market.
Webster Housing Market
Webster's pricing is genuinely harder to pin to a single number, and that's the point — recent data from different sources puts the town's typical sale price anywhere from the high $200,000s to just under $400,000, a wider spread than Penfield's. That range reflects real differences in housing stock: early-1900s homes near the Village core and interior subdivision ranches sit at the lower end, while newer construction, townhome communities like Winding Creek and Brittany Woods, and bay-adjacent properties near communities like The Club at Waters Edge on Irondequoit Bay sit meaningfully higher.
What $350,000–$375,000 Buys in Webster
At this price in Webster, you're generally looking at either a comfortable interior-subdivision colonial with three-plus bedrooms and a two-car garage, or a smaller home closer to the Village core with more walkability but less square footage. It will not typically get you a lakefront or bay-adjacent property — that segment of Webster's market commands a real premium above this range.
Whichever town you're comparing, it helps to understand how comparable sales actually drive a list price rather than relying on a single online estimate. The guide to determining a home's market value breaks down what agents look at beyond square footage.
💰 Property Taxes: A Real, Measurable Difference
Both towns fall under Monroe County, which carries one of the higher property tax burdens in New York State — a reality across nearly every Monroe County suburb, not something unique to either town. But within the county, Penfield and Webster don't carry identical rates. Based on recent effective-rate analysis of actual property records, Penfield's median effective property tax rate runs around 2.65% of assessed value, while Webster's runs lower, around 2.36%. Both sit above the Monroe County median of roughly 2.44% and well above New York State's 1.90% median.
To put that gap in real terms: on a hypothetical $375,000 assessed value, Penfield's rate works out to roughly $9,940 per year, while Webster's works out to roughly $8,850 — a difference of about $1,100 per year, or a little over $90 a month. Over a 10-year hold, that's more than $11,000 in cumulative savings, which is a meaningful number for buyers stretching to hit their price point.
💡 Important context: These are median effective rates, not a quote for any specific property. Your actual bill depends on your assessed value, which school district levy applies, and any exemptions you qualify for — including New York's STAR exemption for primary residences. Always request the actual tax bill history for a specific address from your agent before making an offer. For a broader look at how Monroe County property taxes work, the Rochester property tax guide is a good starting point.
Median household income also runs somewhat higher in Penfield — roughly $115,000 to $119,000 — compared with the low-$90,000s in Webster, which partly reflects the different housing mixes each town offers rather than any single cause.
🏫 School Districts: Both Strong, Different in Size and Structure
School quality is one of the top two or three reasons buyers specifically seek out Penfield or Webster. Both districts are consistently ranked among the strongest in the Greater Rochester region, so the real question is less about which is "better" and more about which structure and program mix fits your family.
Penfield Central School District
Penfield Central is the smaller of the two districts, built around four K–5 elementary schools — including Cobbles and Harris Hill Elementary — feeding into a single Bay Trail Middle School and a single Penfield Senior High School. Enrollment runs roughly 4,600 to 4,700 students districtwide, with a student-teacher ratio around 11-to-1 and state assessment results well above statewide averages. Penfield Senior High offers roughly two dozen clubs and activities alongside its academic programming.
Webster Central School District
Webster Central is a larger district built around two high schools — Webster Schroeder (Warriors), opened in 1969 and located on Ridge Road, and Webster Thomas (Titans) — along with two middle schools, Spry and Willink, and seven elementary schools, including DeWitt Road, Klem Road North and South, Plank Road North and South, Schlegel Road, and State Road. Webster Schroeder alone enrolls over 1,300 students with an 11-to-1 student-teacher ratio, a 96% graduation rate, and an average SAT score around 1250. The larger enrollment base gives Webster Central deeper program and elective offerings than a single-high-school district can typically support.
Local insight: verify the exact zone
School boundaries don't always match town lines near the shared border. Some Penfield-addressed streets close to Webster are actually zoned for Webster Central, and the reverse can be true closer to the boundary. Always verify the exact attendance zone for a specific address rather than assuming based on the town name — and cross-check current data through NYSED, GreatSchools, or Niche before making a school-driven decision.
🌳 Lifestyle & Water Access: Parks and Golf vs. Lakefront and Village Life
This is where Penfield and Webster diverge most visibly, and where personal preference tends to matter more than any objective metric.
Penfield: Parks, Golf, and Trail Access
Penfield's recreational identity centers on its town park system rather than any single waterfront stretch. Harris Whalen Park, at 2126 Penfield Road directly across from Wegmans, hosts the town's Independence Day celebration and serves as its unofficial community gathering spot. The Thousand Acre Swamp Preserve and Four Mile Creek Trail add wooded, wetland trail access on the town's western edge, and the newer Shadow Pines property brings disc golf and pickleball courts to Whalen Road. Shadow Lake Golf & Racquet Club and Penfield Country Club both anchor active golf communities within town.
Webster: Lake Ontario, Village Life, and Xerox
Webster's lifestyle leans directly on the water. Webster Park, a 550-acre Monroe County park on the shore of Lake Ontario, includes a fishing pier, hiking trails, and a family campground. Charles E. Sexton Memorial Park — formerly known as North Ponds Park — hosts community events including the regional Water Lantern Festival, while Kent Park and the adjacent Webster Arboretum add another 84-plus acres of trails and gardens. The Village of Webster's Ridge Road corridor mixes independent shops with the Towne Center at Webster retail hub (Target, Hobby Lobby, Wegmans), giving residents a walkable option that Penfield's spread-out layout doesn't offer in the same way. Xerox's roughly 1,000-acre campus in town is also a notable local landmark and employer, not just a curiosity.
The trade-off for Webster's water access is a stronger lake-effect snow pattern than Penfield's slightly more inland location. If waterfront or near-water living is a priority in either town, the guide to living near water in Rochester NY covers flood considerations and dock or bulkhead upkeep worth knowing before you buy.
🚗 Commute & Everyday Convenience
Penfield and Webster sit close enough together that the commute difference between them is smaller than the difference in daily driving pattern within each town.
Penfield to Downtown Rochester
Roughly 20–25 minutes under normal conditions via I-590, which feeds directly into I-490. Greater Rochester International Airport is roughly 25–30 minutes out. Everyday errands cluster along Routes 441 and 250, anchored by Wegmans, Tops, and Home Depot.
Webster to Downtown Rochester
Roughly 15–25 minutes via Route 104, with the exact time depending heavily on which part of town you're leaving from — bay- and lake-area streets add a few extra minutes of local driving before reaching the main corridors. Ridge Road carries most of Webster's grocery and big-box retail.
Local employment: Webster's Xerox advantage
For buyers who work at or near Xerox's roughly 1,000-acre Webster campus, the commute question largely disappears — it's one of the few Rochester-area employers where a genuinely short, local commute is realistic for a meaningful share of residents. Penfield doesn't have a comparable single-employer anchor of its own.
✅ Who Tends to Choose Penfield — and Who Tends to Choose Webster
After years of walking buyers through both markets, a few clear patterns emerge. Neither town is objectively superior — the right choice depends on which trade-offs matter most to you.
Buyers Who Tend to Choose Penfield
Predictable pricing matters
Penfield's housing stock is more uniform, and its price range is comparatively narrow. Buyers who want fewer surprises when comparing listings tend to find that consistency reassuring.
Golf and town parkland are a priority
With two golf clubs and more than ten town parks and preserves, Penfield appeals strongly to buyers who want recreation close to home without needing waterfront property to get it.
A slightly shorter downtown commute matters
Penfield's direct I-590/I-490 access makes it a practical choice for buyers commuting into the city core or western Monroe County on a regular basis.
Buyers Who Tend to Choose Webster
Lower property taxes matter for monthly budget
Webster's meaningfully lower effective tax rate is a real, recurring financial advantage — often worth over $1,000 a year compared with a similarly assessed Penfield home.
Walkability and a village feel are a priority
The Village of Webster's Ridge Road core gives residents a main-street experience — shops, restaurants, and community events within walking distance — that Penfield's more spread-out hamlet layout doesn't replicate in the same way.
Direct lake access is part of the vision
Buyers who want boating, fishing, or simply being near Lake Ontario as part of daily life will find that Webster delivers in a way Penfield, an inland-bay town, cannot — even accounting for the heavier lake-effect snow that comes with it.
Still weighing other Monroe County suburbs against these two? The best suburbs of Rochester NY guide puts Penfield and Webster in context alongside every other major community in the area.
💡 Buyer's note: It's worth thinking about whether your priorities will shift over the years you plan to own. Buyers focused on monthly budget and predictable pricing today sometimes find their preferences shift toward walkability or waterfront access later — and vice versa. Thinking in a 5- to 10-year window, not just your immediate needs, tends to produce a better decision in this particular comparison.
Weighing Penfield Against Webster?
Kyle Hiscock has helped buyers compare these two towns for years and can walk you through current inventory and school zones.
Talk to Kyle❓ Frequently Asked Questions — Penfield vs Webster NY
Is Penfield or Webster more expensive to buy in?
Penfield's pricing sits in a fairly consistent band, with a 12-month median sale price around $368,000. Webster's range is wider — recent data puts typical sale prices anywhere from the high $200,000s to just under $400,000, depending heavily on whether a home is near the Village core, an interior subdivision, or bay- and lakefront property.
How much lower are property taxes in Webster than Penfield?
Based on recent effective-rate data, Penfield's median effective property tax rate runs around 2.65% of assessed value versus roughly 2.36% in Webster. On a home assessed around $375,000, that translates to roughly $1,100 less per year in Webster — about $90 a month. Always verify the actual tax bill history for a specific address, since exemptions and school levies vary.
Which has the better school district, Penfield or Webster?
Both Penfield Central and Webster Central rank among the top districts in the Greater Rochester region. Penfield Central is smaller and built around a single high school and middle school, while Webster Central is larger, with two high schools, two middle schools, and seven elementary buildings that support broader program and elective offerings. The better fit usually comes down to specific building and program preferences rather than the district overall.
Which town has a shorter commute to downtown Rochester?
Both towns run a similar range — Penfield's typical commute is roughly 20–25 minutes via I-590, while Webster's is roughly 15–25 minutes via Route 104, depending on which part of town you're leaving from. For buyers who work at Xerox's Webster campus specifically, Webster's commute advantage can be dramatic.
Does Penfield or Webster get more snow?
Webster typically sees a stronger lake-effect snow pattern than Penfield, since it sits directly on Lake Ontario. Penfield's slightly more inland location tends to soften — though not eliminate — that lake-effect impact.
Can I be zoned for Webster schools even if my address says Penfield, or vice versa?
Yes. School boundaries don't perfectly match town lines near the shared border, so some Penfield-addressed streets are zoned for Webster Central and vice versa. Always verify the exact attendance zone for a specific address before assuming based on the town name.
Ready to Find the Right Fit?
Whether you're leaning toward Penfield, Webster, or still comparing, Kyle Hiscock can walk you through current inventory, real tax bills, and school zones so you can decide with confidence.
Schedule a Conversation
Kyle Hiscock
Lead Agent • Hiscock Homes at REMAX Realty Group
10 Grove St, Pittsford NY 14534
(585) 704-7095 • Licensed 2011 • Full-time since 2013 • REMAX Hall of Fame
| 443+ Verified Closings | $74M+ Total Sales Volume | 5.0★ Client Rating |
Kyle Hiscock is the lead agent at Hiscock Homes at REMAX Realty Group in Pittsford, NY — a second-generation real estate business serving buyers and sellers across Greater Rochester and the surrounding region. With over 14 years of full-time experience and more than 443 verified closings, Kyle brings deep local knowledge to every transaction.
Kyle operates RochesterRealEstateBlog.com as an educational resource for buyers, sellers, and anyone curious about life in the Rochester area. Since launching the blog in 2013, he's published more than 150 in-depth local articles covering home buying, selling, pricing, inspections, mortgages, and Greater Rochester community guides.
Serving: Irondequoit • Webster • Penfield • Pittsford • Fairport • Brighton • Greece • Gates • Hilton • Brockport • Mendon • Henrietta • Perinton • Churchville • Scottsville • East Rochester • Rush • Honeoye Falls • Chili • Victor • and surrounding communities
