New - 2 Hours Ago
New Construction Homes Around Rochester NY: Towns, Builders, Timelines & Buyer Risks
A five-county guide for buyers considering a builder contract in Monroe, Ontario, Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County.
Quick shortcut: not every county's new-construction market works the same way.
- Buying in a Monroe or Ontario County subdivision: Builder Contracts vs. Standard Contracts
- Buying land and hiring your own builder in Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County: Wayne, Livingston & Orleans Counties
- Not sure where new construction is even happening near you: Monroe County Corridors
New construction has picked up noticeably across Greater Rochester over the past two years, and it isn't limited to a handful of Monroe County subdivisions anymore. Between the Rochester Home Builders' Association — a trade group that has served builders across six counties since 1934 — and the steady stream of subdivision applications moving through town planning boards, there's real building activity happening from Chili to Victor to Sodus.
The catch is that "new construction" means something different depending on where you're looking. In Penfield or Victor, it usually means choosing a lot inside a platted subdivision from a builder with an active sales office. In Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County, it more often means buying a parcel of land and hiring a builder separately to put a house on it. Each path comes with a different contract, a different timeline, and a different tax picture — and none of them work exactly like buying an existing resale home.
This guide walks through where new construction is actually happening across all five counties Hiscock Homes at REMAX Realty Group serves, how builder contracts differ from the standard purchase agreement, what a realistic build timeline looks like, how property taxes change once your home is assessed, and the buyer protections New York law actually gives you. If you want the broader step-by-step basics of buying new — inspections, upgrades, walkthroughs — our general new construction buying guide covers that ground; this one is about geography, contracts, and risk.
New Construction at a Glance by County
| County | Typical Pattern | Where It's Concentrated | What to Expect |
| Monroe | Builder-run subdivisions | Penfield, Webster, Henrietta, Chili, Churchville, Spencerport | Most competition, tightest inventory windows |
| Ontario | Fast-growing subdivision corridor | Victor, Farmington | Highest volume of active subdivisions, real lot premiums |
| Wayne | Build-on-your-own-lot & lakefront | Macedon, Sodus, Williamson, Ontario (town) | Fewer subdivisions; land purchase usually comes first |
| Livingston | Rural custom build | Avon, Geneseo, Lakeville | Lower land costs, longer well/septic timelines |
| Orleans | Land-first, custom build | Albion, Medina, Holley | Very few subdivisions; expect a separate land purchase and builder contract |
Jump to a Section
Monroe County Corridors
Monroe County has the most new-construction activity in the region simply because it has the most builders working at once. In Penfield, Crosstown Custom Homes is building custom sites at Stafford Park, a wooded cul-de-sac location, along with the Wellsbrook Townhouses and the zero-step-entry Barclay Park community. A short drive away, Highland Estates offers sixteen premium two-plus-acre lots, and Shady Rock is known for its larger lot sizes. If you want the fuller picture of day-to-day life in the town — not just what's being built — our Living in Penfield NY guide covers neighborhoods, schools, and cost of living in depth. Worth knowing if you're set on Penfield schools specifically: part of Penfield is actually zoned to Webster Central School District rather than Penfield CSD, so confirm the district before you fall in love with a lot — our guide to school districts near Rochester breaks down how these boundaries actually work.
Redstone Builders works the Webster–Penfield–Victor–Greece–Henrietta corridor with communities like Tall Birch Glen and Shady Rock. Henrietta has active production from Pinnacle Homes and Morrell Builders — our Living in Henrietta NY guide is a good next stop if that corridor is on your list. On the west side, Holding Homes is building in Chili, Sortino Properties and Faber Builders are both active in Churchville, and Lopresti Homes Corporation has communities in Spencerport. Faber Builders in particular has deep Rochester roots — the family's local history dates back to 1905, with the building company itself founded in 1983, and it continues to build across Rochester, Henrietta, and Greece.
If you want a broader view of who's building across the county, the Rochester Home Builders' Association — a trade group serving six counties since 1934 — maintains a member directory at FindTheHomePros.com. It's a useful starting point before you commit to a single builder's sales office.
Ontario County: Victor & Farmington
If one corridor in the five-county area is the center of new-home construction right now, it's Victor and Farmington. Woodstone Custom Homes' Stone Brook community is bringing 85 homesites online in two phases, surrounded by 66 acres of nature preserve with access to the Auburn Trail. Highline Park is a newer luxury townhome community in Victor where HOA-covered services handle exterior maintenance. Gerber Homes builds in the Victor & Farmington Road community near Macedon, and Polidori & Ferri Custom Homes has multiple active sites in Victor as well. Just over the line in Farmington, the Farmbrook community falls within the Canandaigua City School District rather than Victor's — another example of how school zoning doesn't always follow the town line you'd expect.
The Town of Victor's own planning board pipeline tells the story better than any listing site: recent applications include an 85-lot single-family subdivision on 100 acres along East Victor Road, a 74-lot subdivision on 158 acres off Brownsville Road, and a 45-unit townhome project called Banjo Run — on top of several multi-unit and townhome projects already under review. That volume of subdivision activity is unmatched anywhere else in the five-county service area right now, which also means lot premiums and HOA-covered communities are more common here than in Monroe County.
Local insight: Victor and Farmington subdivisions tend to sell out phases quickly. If you're set on a specific builder's community, ask about the next phase release date rather than waiting for the current phase to list — by the time a lot shows up on a portal, it's often already under contract.
Wayne, Livingston & Orleans Counties: Build-Your-Own-Lot Territory
The further you get from Monroe and Ontario counties, the less "new construction" looks like a subdivision with a model home and a sales office — and the more it looks like buying a piece of land and hiring a builder to put a house on it.
Wayne County
Gerber Homes is active in Sodus, building near Sodus Bay Heights Golf Course, in addition to its Macedon community. Most of the county's new-home activity is scattered acreage lots rather than platted subdivisions, though there are exceptions — Bay Shore Heights, a subdivision overlooking Sodus Bay, carries an HOA that maintains more than 21 acres of shared land, a reminder that even a build-on-your-own-lot county can have HOA dues if you're buying into a lakefront-adjacent community.
Livingston County
Livingston County leans almost entirely toward build-on-your-own-lot construction rather than platted subdivisions — more than two dozen builders serve the county on that basis, according to regional new-home listings. Land costs run meaningfully lower here than in Monroe or Ontario, but plan for longer permitting timelines tied to well and septic approval — those steps simply don't exist for a lot already tied into municipal water and sewer in a Monroe County subdivision.
Orleans County
Orleans County is almost entirely a land-first market. Around Albion, Medina, and Holley, most available parcels are wooded or open acreage with road frontage or a deeded easement rather than lots inside an existing subdivision. That means more upfront due diligence — confirming well and septic suitability, drainage, and buildable area — before a builder will commit to a fixed price, since there's no prior subdivision infrastructure doing that work for you.
Builder Contracts vs. the Standard NY Purchase Contract
The purchase agreement a builder hands you at their sales office isn't the same document you'd sign to buy an existing resale home. It's usually drafted entirely by the builder's attorney, and it's built to protect the builder, not you. A few differences worth knowing before you sign anything:
Staged deposits, not one earnest money check
Many builder contracts collect deposits in stages — at signing, at permit issuance, at foundation, sometimes again at drywall — rather than a single earnest money deposit held at contract signing.
Lot premiums and change orders sit outside the base price
The advertised base price rarely includes a walkout lot, cul-de-sac location, or water view — those are separate premiums. Upgrades and change orders are typically priced through the builder's own design center, often above what the same finish would cost through an outside contractor.
Completion dates are usually estimates, not guarantees
Look closely at the completion-date language. Many builder contracts protect the builder with an estimated completion window and carve-outs for labor or material delays rather than a firm, penalty-backed date.
Standard contingencies may be limited or absent
Financing, inspection, and attorney-review protections that are routine in a resale contract aren't automatic in a builder contract — they need to be negotiated in. If you're buying land separately and hiring a builder, understanding how a suitable-property contingency works is especially relevant, since it protects your deposit if the land turns out not to be buildable as planned.
Do You Need Your Own Buyer's Agent?
The friendly person at the builder's model home is a real estate professional — but their fiduciary duty runs to the builder, not to you. That's true even if they're pleasant, helpful, and clearly know the community inside and out. Their job is to sell the builder's inventory on the builder's terms.
The practical issue is timing: most builders record your visit as "unrepresented" the moment you tour a model home, call the sales office, or register online without naming a buyer's agent — and many won't retroactively recognize an agent after that first contact, even if you sign with one a week later. If you want your own representation, line it up before your first visit rather than after. Our guide on why buyers hire their own agent covers the reasoning in more depth, but for new construction specifically, an agent who has worked with local builders before can also flag which builders in a given corridor have a track record of hitting their completion estimates versus which routinely miss them.
Considering a Lot in Victor, Penfield, or Anywhere in Between?
Let's talk through which builders and communities actually fit what you're looking for.
Start the ConversationRealistic Building Timelines
"How long will this actually take" is one of the first questions worth asking any builder, and the honest answer depends heavily on where you're building. A spec home that's already permitted and partway through construction can close in a matter of weeks. A custom build inside an established Monroe or Ontario County subdivision, with utilities already run to the lot, typically takes somewhere in the six-to-twelve-month range from signed contract to closing, depending on the builder's current backlog and material lead times.
Rural custom builds in Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County usually take longer, since well drilling, septic design and approval, and driveway/culvert permitting all have to happen before the builder can even break ground. And that's just the individual home — the subdivision itself can take years to reach the point where lots are available at all. The Town of Victor's own planning board records show subdivision applications that were first submitted years before final approval, which is a useful reminder that "coming soon" phases in a builder's marketing can mean very different things depending on where that approval process actually stands.
Whatever the timeline looks like, get your financing lined up early. A long build changes how you think about your mortgage — many buyers use a construction-to-permanent loan that converts once the certificate of occupancy is issued, and rate-lock windows on those products vary by lender. Talking to a lender before you sign anything is worth it; our guide to getting pre-approved for a mortgage in Rochester NY walks through what that conversation should cover.
Property Taxes After You Move In
This is the piece that catches new construction buyers off guard most often. New York assesses property as it exists on the local taxable status date — so if your home isn't finished by that date, the assessment for that tax year may reflect land value only, not the completed house. That can make the "estimated taxes" a builder quotes during construction look artificially low. Once your certificate of occupancy is issued and the assessor picks up the full improvement, expect a real increase the following tax cycle. Some subdivisions also carry a temporary infrastructure-related exemption under state law that specifically ends once the certificate of occupancy is issued, which is another reason the number you see during construction may not be the number you'll actually pay.
There's also a common misconception around the STAR exemption. New York closed the STAR exemption to new applicants back in 2016 — if you're buying your first home in New York, you won't get an automatic exemption on your tax bill. You'll need to actively register with the state for the STAR credit, which arrives as a separate check or direct deposit rather than a line-item reduction. It's an easy step to miss when you're focused on closing.
One more thing worth asking your assessor about directly: some New York towns and school districts have adopted a local-option exemption specifically for first-time homebuyers of newly constructed homes. It doesn't apply everywhere, and eligibility rules are specific, but it costs nothing to ask before you assume it doesn't apply to you. And because tax rates genuinely differ by county — Ontario County's rates run notably different from Monroe County's, for instance — it's worth reading our full breakdown of property taxes in Rochester and Monroe County before you compare a Monroe County lot to one in Ontario, Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County.
Your Builder Warranty Rights Under New York Law
New York doesn't leave new-construction buyers entirely to whatever the builder's paperwork says. General Business Law Article 36-B creates what's called a Housing Merchant Implied Warranty, and it exists automatically in the sale of a new home whether or not the contract mentions it. It covers three tiers: one year against defects from unskillful construction, two years on plumbing, electrical, heating, cooling, and ventilation systems, and six years against material structural defects.
Two nuances matter for buyers in this region specifically. First, this implied warranty generally doesn't apply if you already owned the land before construction began — which describes a lot of custom builds in Wayne, Livingston, and Orleans County, so ask your builder directly what warranty coverage you'll actually have in that scenario. Second, a builder is legally allowed to replace the implied warranty with a limited warranty of their own, but only if it's clearly disclosed, provided to you before you sign, and conspicuously states that it's replacing your statutory protections. If a builder's contract mentions a limited warranty, read it before closing, not after a problem shows up — and if you find a defect once you're in the home, New York requires written notice to the builder before you can take further action, so keep a paper trail from day one.
Buyer Risk Checklist Before You Sign
Contract & deposit structure
Know exactly when each deposit is due, what triggers it, and under what conditions any portion is refundable.
Your own representation
Line up a buyer's agent before your first model home visit or sales-office phone call, not after.
Site conditions, especially on rural lots
In Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County, confirm well yield, septic suitability, and buildable area before you're locked into a fixed price.
Lot premiums & change orders
Get every premium and upgrade price in writing before you sign — verbal promises from a sales office rarely survive a change in personnel.
Completion timeline & rate lock
Match your mortgage rate-lock window to the builder's realistic completion estimate, not their optimistic one.
Final walkthrough & warranty documentation
Save every warranty document the builder provides, and treat your final walkthrough as your last real chance to catch issues before closing. Our final walk-through (blue tape) checklist walks through exactly what to look for.
⚠️ Before You Visit a Model Home
If you want your own buyer's agent involved, arrange it before you tour a community, call the sales office, or register online — not after. Most builders treat that first contact as the point where your representation status is locked in.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions — New Construction in Greater Rochester
Do I need a real estate agent to buy new construction in Rochester NY?
You aren't required to have one, but the agent at the builder's sales office represents the builder, not you. Bringing your own buyer's agent before your first visit gives you independent contract review, negotiation, and inspection guidance at no direct cost to you in most cases, since builders typically pay the buyer's agent commission.
Are property taxes higher on new construction homes?
Not necessarily higher long-term, but often higher than the "estimated" number quoted during construction. Many new homes are assessed on land value alone until the certificate of occupancy is issued, so the tax bill can jump meaningfully once the completed home is fully assessed.
How long does it take to build a new home in the Rochester area?
A custom build inside an established Monroe or Ontario County subdivision typically runs six to twelve months from signed contract to closing. Rural custom builds in Wayne, Livingston, or Orleans County often take longer due to well and septic permitting.
Is there a warranty on new construction homes in New York?
Yes. New York's Housing Merchant Implied Warranty automatically covers one year on skilled workmanship, two years on major systems, and six years on structural defects — though it generally doesn't apply if you owned the land before construction began, and builders can substitute their own limited warranty if properly disclosed.
Which towns have the most new construction right now?
Victor and Farmington in Ontario County currently have the highest volume of active subdivisions in the five-county service area, followed by Penfield, Henrietta, and Chili in Monroe County.
Ready to Talk Through Your New Construction Options?
Whether you're comparing a Victor subdivision to a custom build in Livingston County, we'll help you weigh the contract, the timeline, and the true cost — before you sign anything.
Get in Touch
Kyle Hiscock
Lead Agent • Hiscock Homes at REMAX Realty Group
10 Grove St, Pittsford NY 14534
(585) 704-7095 • Licensed 2011 • Full-time since 2013 • REMAX Hall of Fame
| 443+ Verified Closings | $74M+ Total Sales Volume | 5.0★ Client Rating |
Kyle Hiscock is the lead agent at Hiscock Homes at REMAX Realty Group in Pittsford, NY — a second-generation real estate business serving buyers and sellers across Greater Rochester and the surrounding region. With over 14 years of full-time experience and more than 443 verified closings, Kyle brings deep local knowledge to every transaction.
Kyle operates RochesterRealEstateBlog.com as an educational resource for buyers, sellers, and anyone curious about life in the Rochester area. Since launching the blog in 2013, he's published more than 150 in-depth local articles covering home buying, selling, pricing, inspections, mortgages, and Greater Rochester community guides.
Serving: Irondequoit • Webster • Penfield • Pittsford • Fairport • Brighton • Greece • Gates • Hilton • Brockport • Mendon • Henrietta • Perinton • Churchville • Scottsville • East Rochester • Rush • Honeoye Falls • Chili • Victor • and surrounding communities
